Online college is not going anywhere.

On May 12, California State University’s 23-campus system was the first major U.S. post-secondary institution to admit the inevitable: fall 2020 is moving online. Even as more and more American states facilitate restrictions, many experts to predict another more catastrophic wave in the fall. Of course, colleges and universities can claim what they want, in hopes of buttress an enlistment hemorrhage, but come to: Why intentionally summon tens of thousands of young people with questionable hygiene, poor judgmentand a pathological need for to gather from anywhere in the world to a single campus if there is a safer alternative?

Of course, it’s not that simple. Moving College Online is sure, but sub-optimal. When Spring 2020 classes rushed into cyberspace, this emergency measure was greeted with a resounding chorus of offended screams from both student and teacher. Instructors who had never taught online classes (many of them vehemently to oppose practice) suddenly found themselves giving Zoom talks to glassy, ​​anxious college students with their “homeschooled” kids wreaking havoc in the background. Some institutions have gone pass/fail. Others does not have. No one knew what they were doing, everyone had to do it anyway, and it was, and continues to be, not great.

Meanwhile, the inevitable digitalization of America’s college has dire consequences for anyone who attends or works in one. It is an inevitable fact that some post-secondary institutions not survive the pandemic. Some already have firm, citing COVID-19 as the cause of death. Moreover, countless schools have already started layoffs, furloughs, pay cuts and other desperate measures, so that even colleges still standing in the After Times may be withered husks of themselves.

If you were planning to start college in the fall of 2020, postponing might seem like a good idea right now. If you’re currently a student and virtual Spring 2020 was a nightmare, it might seem like a good idea to take a year off. But really, what else are you going to do with your time, Junior? To travel? Party? look Friends with your parents?

While it’s appropriate to mourn the lost experience on campus, it’s also time to think about online college in a different binary: not online vs in person, corn good use of your pandemic time versus misuse of it. The traditional college experience as we know it currently floats intact in the same metaphorical cryogenic freezer as the other Before Times artifacts: dinner parties, Tinder dates and, I dunno, not crying your way to sleep every night. In its place is a different experience that many rightly call decreases, but is still better than the alternatives. You’re stuck at home anyway. Why not tick your requirements?

The good news is that fall 2020 doesn’t have to be like spring 2020. and institutions have time to prepare. Even those of us expected to teach in person (as I am, we’ll see) need to create online twin versions of our courses, ready to go immediately when we, or one of our students, get sick.

Recently, Cassie Christopher, a law professor at Texas Tech request quarantined middle schoolers tweet what they’d like their professors and institutions to know “if” online college continues in the fall. And while the overwhelming response included conflicting reproaches—More asynchronous teaching (where the lectures are recorded and which we then watch each time)! More synchronous teaching (where the class is “regular” but on Zoom)! – there were common sources of frustration that instructors, institutions, and students have the power to set for the fall term.

I have, for example, heard the strange horror story of teachers trying to reproduce the model in person by being the same extreme badass on ranking and presence they are in the flesh. This is not helpful. Anyone who doesn’t offer flexible due dates is a fool for no good reason, and the same goes for the multiple homework options (three short items Where a long ! Four small exams Where a cumulative!). Notes, on the other hand, are more delicate. The ideal and most humane thing to do would be to give all students a pass/fail option, but this often requires bureaucratic clearance (Ugh), so the best thing to do is simply to provide students with as many flexible paths to success as possible. This includes registration and caption or transcribe all Zoom conferences and ideally make all live sessions optional, closer to working hours during class time.

Moreover, my extremely scientific study has proven that everyone, everywhere, hates mandatory discussion forums (very good, many students do). I can see why instructors use them – I’ve used them – but there’s no way a glorified Reddit thread can replicate the human interaction of small seminars or discussion sections, and it’s time to stop to try. (Fortunately, there is a solution: craft the boards extra creditwhich to the uninitiated is a magic spell that, when spoken, causes students to do something with great enthusiasm.)

Institutional financial changes are also absolutely necessary. Students and their parents are already complaining for refunds for Spring 2020, and as the U.S. health and economic situation worsens, contentious appetites for restitution will also inflame. Yes, all institutions face financial catastrophe, and a government that views academia with open contempt will be reluctant to bail it out (unless it is the Betsy DeVos Institute for Jesus Studies and Ayn Rand).

And yet, there is no other solution: the fee structure for the online-only version of the “regular” college must be different. Although it is actually more expensive to deliver classes online than in person (the instructor skinny salary more tech), non-academic fees, such as those for student activities, use of facilities, and (obviously) housing, simply need to be eliminated. Of course, the online experience might not be worth the fancy price, and if so, do I have a secret for you: Expensive “brand” school gives transfer students exactly the same degree as it gives to those who start in the first year. New high school graduates should consider enrolling in their local or regional public school for a year or two, where prices are low and online education has been part of the curriculum for years. (Students currently enrolled at an expensive location can research how many transfer credits and where their expensive institution is accepting from!)

Finally, even if the institutions do not adapt and the professors remain recalcitrant, the students can save themselves from being miserable for another semester (at less) of online college. The reason e-learning is such a disastrous substitute for in-person classes is that it is not a substitute for the in-person class. The idea that an ordinary classroom can simply be made “virtual” but otherwise remain unchanged is ridiculous; online learning is not just a “virtual classroom”; it’s a completely different medium that requires a different set of expectations.

Essentially, online courses are set up differently because online brains learn differently or, more specifically, because being online can Craft our different brains. A paper 2019 in the peer-reviewed journal World Psychiatry, which studied the effect of internet exposure on the human brain, argued that “the internet can produce both acute and lasting alterations” in the way people pay attention, retain information and interact socially – you know, the things needed to get through college. Specifically: the “online brain” is so different that not only has it permanently introduced new behaviors (like inadvertently checking a device), but being online can have changed the functioning of our brain, to the detriment of attention span, memory, and emotional stability. As with all very recent science scholarship, this article is only a study of the “internet brain”, and is not foolproof – but, as many students found out the hard way in the spring of 2020, follow an online course has often resulted in being too impatient to absorb anything, forgetting a huge amount of content, and then getting really crazy about it.

But, more good news: If students come into their online classes with a fortified mindset, essentially a kind of defense against the dark web arts of mindfulness (I notice my attention slipping), the discipline (I will not treat this assignment as a BuzzFeed quiz), self-compassion (I’m not gonna be my best here and that’s fine) and patience (my teacher is as anxious and stressed as me) – combined with the reminder that online school always beats real alternatives, fall 2020 might even be getting closer to tolerable.

Yes, it is disheartening to know that, like everything else, there is no end in sight to COVID-related disruptions to university life. Yeah, there’s nothing quite like college in person, and I’m just as eager as the rest of you to get back to the actual classroom. But, like the virus, online higher education is going nowhere. So we might as well try the old college.

For more on the impact of the coronavirus, listen to What Next.

Future Tense is a partnership between Slate,
New Americaand
Arizona State University
which examines emerging technologies, public policy and society.

Comments are closed.